Click here to send in your own Weird Soda Review!

Saturday, May 2, 2009

Pennsylvania Punch

During my pilgrimage to Galco's, I overheard the store manager expounding enthusiastically to a group of customers about a certain Weird Soda. I didn't catch the specifics--alas, I arrived too late--but I do know that it involved the original formula for Coke supposedly belonging to a different company. The hint of intrigue in the soda world piqued my curiosity, and I made sure to pick up a sample of the soda which was the subject of his exposition.
It's something called Pennsylvania Punch. Apparently, it's related to another soda called Delaware Punch. According to Galco's web site, this is the original 1924 version of the Delaware Punch formula, re-bottled. Delaware punch is apparently no longer available, at least not made with real sugar. The phrasing on Galco's site implies a sense of deep betrayal at the fact that Delaware punch no longer uses real sugar. There is the further implication that Delaware Punch was purchased by Coke; this, perhaps, led to the Corn Syrup Sullying of 1924, and the subsequent Pennsylvania Rebellion, the fruits of which I am about to quaff.
The label has a picture of grapes, and the soda does have a faint purple tinge to the brown, so I don't know about the Coke connection. Ah well; let's do this thing.

Where and when: purchased in April 2009 at Galco's, Los Angeles
Color: medium clear brown with a hint of purple. Neat label, looks homemade.
Scent: Hey, this is a real bottle cap; I can't twist it off!
The scent is grape, with a hint of iciness, maybe a touch of cream. Intriguing and pleasant. Quite sweet.
Taste: Ooh, that's neat. Grape, but complicated. The grape is pretty much like the grape of a Popsicle (not a bad thing), with a strong sweet fading into tart. There's something else, though--some sort of volatility, something which gives it some headiness. It's almost like a bit of cream soda, but not really. There's complexity in the grape. It's a bit too sweet for my tastes--almost painfully so--but I like the taste aside from that.
Kibbitzer-in-Chief: "Tastes like snow cone. Old snow cone--not like the kind you get from a cart, but like a raspada, a shaved ice. But it tastes defective because it's liquid. This snow cone is defective!"
So a pleasant defective grape sno-cone. There we have it.
Nothing whatsoever like Coke. I don't know what Coke did with this--do they even make a grape soda?--but this is pretty nice. This, for what it's worth, is bottled by the Natrona company.

Quaff rating: 3.5. A bit cloying, but nice.
Cough rating: 0.5. Just the excessive sweetness.

4 comments:

  1. it is as close as i have tasted to delaware punch. that's good business

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have emailed coca cola numerous times asking why they do not re release Delaware Punch onto the market. They could give no answer except that it is available in certain markets.
    I grew up with it. It was my favorite soft drink. I am in California. What good does it do that you can still find it in Louisiana? What good does it do that it's $10-$12 for a 12 pack of cans on amazon but the shipping is $16.99. Coca Cola is STUPID for not putting it back on the market. We baby boomers who grew up with it loved it.
    BOO Coca Cola. Who wants a product you can clean chrome with. Give us Delaware Punch!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. California won't allow Delaware Punch imported to or sold in the state due to some Red Dye prohibition. Once again the Nanny State pokes its nose where it's not wanted.

      Delete
  3. My all-time childhood favorite, it has been a dim memory for decades. I live near Galco's. I had read about the reissuing as Pennsylvania Punch, but never thought to go in and try a bottle. Yesterday, I stopped in and bought a few bottles. It is pretty close to my olfactory memory. I remember the color being more intense, like pomegranate mixed with a little purple and also that there was more body to the liquid (i.e. thicker), but other than that, the flavor is right on. So happy to have rediscovered it.

    ReplyDelete

 
Creative Commons License
This work by http://www.weirdsodareview.com is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License.